16 Mill Street


Downtown, Edgartown, MA 02539

Residential Property Image/jpeg #1
1 / 42
Interested in this property?

Single Family Residence in Downtown, Edgartown

4 bedrooms


4 bathrooms


2090 SqFt


0.11 acres


MLS #40748

VINTAGE CHARMER IN EDGARTOWN VILLAGE. Set behind a privet hedge with an iconic American flag hung above the doorway, this Edgartown Village home is loaded with quintessential Vineyard charm and offers all the best of in-town living. Built originally in 1908, the home was completely renovated in 2021 pursuant to plans by noted architect, Patrick Ahearn. The winning result is a beautifully renovated home with fresh touches and modern amenities, all within the classic historic facade. The welcoming interior boasts impressive features such as hardwood floors, v-groove and beaded board paneling, custom millwork and built-ins, plus a wood-burning fireplace. The gourmet cook's kitchen features cottage-style details with a vintage double sink, a large dining hutch for storage and top-notch stainless appliances throughout. French doors open out onto a spacious 240-square-foot covered porch and bluestone terrace, perfect for summer entertaining and relaxing -- all while enjoying the private oasis of the beautifully landscaped and fenced back yard. This absolutely charming home is move-in perfect and is being offered turnkey -- with stylish designer furnishings, artwork and accessories*. The property has an established rental history, with $70k in gross rentals on the books for Summer 2023 – and there are currently open weeks in late August for a buyer to rent or enjoy themselves. One step inside and you will be enchanted by this very special home!

Property highlights




Public Beach

Town Sewer


Town Water

Property Details

Association Fee:
Association Fee Includes:
A built-in hatch on the covered back porch opens to the newly poured concrete basement that provides additional storage space.
Fireplace Features:
Wood-Burning Fireplace in Living Room
Hardwood + Tile
Foundation Types:
Poured Concrete
Frontage Type:
Interior Features:
AC,Ins,Irr,OShFloor 1: The foyer opens into a welcoming Living Room with wood-burning fireplace flanked with custom built-ins and a formal dining nook located just beyond. The open Kitchen/Dining and Family Room is bathed in sunlight and features French doors that open out to the covered porch, bluestone terrace and private fenced yard. There is a cozy Den with built-ins and the hallway between the Den and Kitchen offers access to a full bath with shower, a pantry and laundry area.Floor 2: The staircase to the second floor opens into a Sitting Area/Lounge and there are four bedrooms, two of which have beautiful en suite baths with glass walk-in showers -- and the other two bedrooms share access to a full bath with tub/shower.
Link MLS Comments:
Located on the southwest corner of Plantingfield Way and Mill Street. *NOTE: A list of Seller exclusions wikll be provided.
Lot Features:
Professionally Landscaped Yard With Full Privacy Fence
Parking Features:
Off-Street Parking
Possible Use:
Assessed Building Value:
Assessed Land Value:

Price History

May 08, 2023

Tax Information

This property was most recently assessed in 2023. It has been assessed at a value of $2,223,700. The annual tax responsibility for this property is $5,603.72.

Contact an Agent
Phone number
+1 (508) 338-2495

Property Location

©2022 LINK, All Rights Reserved. Not responsible for misinformation or typographical errors. Prices are subject to change without notice. Listed by Compass | Point B.