39 Sarita Walker Road


Residential Property Image/jpeg #1
1 / 35
Interested in this property?

Single Family Residence in South Shore, West Tisbury

6 bedrooms


4 bathrooms


3540 SqFt


3 acres


MLS #39860

Private West Tisbury estate on 3 acres with access to Watcha Pond. This distinctive offering includes a four-bedroom main home, a two-bedroom guest house and an oversized two-bay garage with additional living space on the second level. Enjoy the casual elegance of this beautifully maintained 1830’s farmhouse with quality workmanship and thoughtful detailing throughout. The farmhouse had a complete frame-off restoration in the mid-90s to offer modernized living. Charming wood beams and custom built-ins are featured throughout the home along with a gourmet kitchen, sun-filled dining room, living room with brick fireplace, antique wood floors and updated bedrooms and baths. Privately sited from the main house is a charming guest house with wonderful views of the surrounding meadow. Watcha Pond is a pristine fresh water pond on the south shore of Martha’s Vineyard perfect for kayaking and paddle boarding. Offering sweeping pastoral views, a generous yard, lovely cultivated gardens and native landscape, this property is a true island retreat.

Property highlights




Public Beach

Septic Tank


Well Water

Property Details

Association Fee:
Association Fee Includes:
The basement has been finished and offers many possibilities. The house underwent a majorframe-off renovation with a new foundation which created a full heightdry basement with ample storage. The laundry room is located at the base of the stairs and contains many of the utilities. There is a media room and another large open area great for an at-home gym or recreational room. A half bath and additional storage makes the basement a very diverseadded bonus living space.
Fireplace Features:
Foundation Types:
Poured Concrete
Frontage Type:
Interior Features:
Ins,Media,OShFloor 1: Entering the main house through the entry way you are instantly aware of the well-maintained historic features of the home. The wide floorboards and exposed beams in the original section of the house are carried into the recently updated kitchen and dining room addition. The gourmet kitchen has ample storage, gas range, and coffee bar for the coffee enthusiast. One bedroom and full bathroom is located off the kitchen, while the other bedroom, currently being used as a study, is just off the living room. The large living room offers multiple sitting areas with working fireplace. Off the main entry is an office and a second full bath.Floor 2: The second floor holds two large bedrooms and a third full bathroom. Each room has vaulted ceilings and large windows to allow abundant light and cool breezes from the south shore.
Link MLS Comments:
Owners are in residence, so please no drivebys. Take Joe Walker Road off of Edgartown West Tisbury Road. At the end stay right and take your first left. Property is the second driveway on the right. Note: Option to purchase this home turn-key with furnishings. Please inquire.
Lot Features:
Access to Watcha PondYes
Parking Features:
Possible Use:
Assessed Building Value:
Assessed Land Value:

Price History

March 13, 2023
July 11, 2022

Tax Information

This property was most recently assessed in 2023. It has been assessed at a value of $2,806,200. The annual tax responsibility for this property is $12,235.03.

Contact an Agent
Phone number
+1 (508) 338-2495

Property Location

©2022 LINK, All Rights Reserved. Not responsible for misinformation or typographical errors. Prices are subject to change without notice. Listed by Wallace & Co. Sotheby's.